Amish chicken casserole recipes are hearty, homemade meals made with simple ingredients like chicken, noodles, rice, creamy sauces, and buttery toppings. Whether you need an easy weeknight dinner, a cozy meal for cold weather, or a casserole for a potluck, these old-fashioned Amish chicken casseroles are filling, family-friendly, and easy to make.
This collection includes creamy chicken noodle casseroles, chicken and rice bake, cheesy pasta dishes, Amish chicken roasht, and other homestyle comfort food recipes your family will love.
Why You'll Love These Amish Chicken Casseroles
- Made with simple pantry ingredients
- Easy and filling family dinners
- Cozy old-fashioned comfort food
- Great way to use leftover chicken
- Perfect for potlucks and gatherings
- Many can be made ahead or frozen
- Kid-friendly and budget-friendly meals
Amish Casserole Recipes With Chicken
1. Amish Chicken and Rice Casserole
Dinner doesn't get any easier than this Amish chicken and rice casserole. It's a quick meal to put together that requires only one pan and a few simple ingredients like boneless chicken thighs, rice, cream of mushroom soup, and seasonings.
This easy chicken and rice bake is a kid-approved, amazingly delicious, and comforting dish that's perfect for any day of the week.
2. Amish-style Chicken Gumbo
Amish Chicken Gumbo features layers of sliced bread and cooked chicken, topped with a creamy sauce, cheese slices, and buttered bread crumbs for a delightful crispy finish.
This Amish chicken casserole is a warm, comforting dish perfect for family dinners. Every bite offers a delightful combination of creamy and crispy textures, making it a cozy and satisfying meal for any occasion.
3. Easy Amish Macaroni Casserole
Embrace the comforting flavors of traditional Amish cuisine with this Easy Amish Macaroni Casserole recipe. This tasty casserole dish is a delicious blend of tender macaroni, savory meat, and green peas in a creamy, cheesy sauce.
Whether you opt for the savory richness of chicken, the smoky goodness of ham, or the hearty taste of beef, this versatile dish promises to be a wholesome and satisfying favorite at your family's dinner table.
You don't even need to boil the pasta. Just mix it up in the evening, put it in the fridge overnight, then bake it the next day for a quick and comforting dinner.
4. Chickenetti
Chickenetti is an easy Amish casserole made with spaghetti noodles and chicken in a creamy sauce. This kid-friendly chicken and noodles casserole is perfect for a simple family dinner or potluck.
You will want to tuck away this Amish Chicken Casserole Recipe for future meal plans!
5. Amish Wedding Chicken Roasht - Chicken and Stuffing
Chicken or turkey roast (Roasht) is served at every Amish wedding in Lancaster County, PA.
Amish Roasht is simply chicken or turkey meat that has been roasted, removed from the bones, and cut into small pieces. It is then added to a big bowl of delicious bread stuffing. It is so yummy with mashed potatoes and gravy.
6. Chicken and Corn Casserole
This Amish Chicken and Corn Casserole is made from scratch with simple ingredients. It's a cozy, comforting, and easy dinner that's ready for the table in less than 45 minutes!
Your family will love the creamy combination of tender chicken, sweet corn, and a buttery Ritz crackers crumb topping. Add a side salad or roasted veggies for a quick weeknight meal. (Recipe from the Seasoned Mom)
7. Chicken and Pasta Casserole
Creamy Parmesan Chicken and Pasta Casserole is everything you would expect it to be by its name. Made with diced cooked chicken (or rotisserie chicken), rotini pasta, 2 cups of chicken broth, milk, and parmesan cheese, it's simple, quick, and delicious! (Recipe from Mandy's Recipe Box)
8. Amish Chicken, Noodle, and Broccoli Casserole
This Easy Chicken Casserole is filled with all of the wonderful things that make a casserole great. It's a mixture of warm chicken, veggies, pasta, and a creamy sauce made with heavy cream and canned or fresh mushrooms.
A delicious, from-scratch casserole that is filling, satisfying, and something the whole family will enjoy. (Recipe from Little House Living)
9. Chicken Supreme Casserole
A cheesy chicken and macaroni casserole with Velveeta cheese and cream of chicken soup. (Recipe from Amish 365)
10. Chicken and Noodles Casserole
This Amish Chicken Casserole uses flavor-packed rotisserie chicken as a base and is topped with a savory and simple white sauce, fresh mushrooms, and perfectly cooked medium egg noodles.
A simple and delicious casserole with an incredibly easy white sauce, this hearty casserole makes the perfect supper to come home to. (Recipe from I Am Homesteader)
11. Amish Chicken & Pasta Casserole (adapted to slow cooker)
This creamy chicken casserole with penne pasta, peas, and a cheesy homemade sauce comes together in minutes and is perfect for those times when you just need a quick meal that you know the whole family (including toddlers) will love.
The original recipe has been adapted to be made in the slow cooker, which makes this Amish casserole from scratch a great recipe for when you need to prep ahead! (Recipe from This Mom Cooks)
12. Amish Chicken and Noodles
Amish Chicken and Noodles are amazing. This simple recipe uses only 6 ingredients and takes about 30 minutes to make. It's perfect for weeknight dinners when you're trying to get dinner ready in a jiffy. (Recipe from Can't Stay out of the Kitchen)
13. Chicken Pot Pie
PA Dutch chicken pot pie is a brothy comfort food similar to chicken noodle soup. This dish features delicious homemade noodle squares in slightly thickened broth with chicken and vegetables.
A delightful Amish country recipe that can be made with cooked chicken breast or leftover chicken. Not so much a casserole recipe, but it is a great dish for a chilly evening!
Tips for Making Chicken Casseroles
- Use rotisserie chicken to save time.
- Most casseroles taste just as good the next day.
- Freeze casseroles before baking for easy meals later.
- Add a side salad or vegetables, or do what many Amish families do and serve applesauce and homemade bread alongside the casserole.
Frequently Asked Questions
Rotisserie chicken, leftover chicken, cooked chicken breasts, and cooked chicken thighs all work great in chicken casseroles.
Yes, many chicken casseroles can be assembled ahead of time and refrigerated until ready to bake. Many of them also make great freezer meals.
Most chicken casseroles freeze well either before or after baking. Store them tightly covered and thaw before reheating.
Amish casseroles are popular because they are simple, comforting, budget-friendly, and easy to feed to a large family. Check out this post with 17 easy Amish casserole recipes.
More Amish Casserole Recipes
- Dairy Casserole
- Yumasetti Casserole
- Amish Breakfast Casserole
- Underground Ham Casserole
- Shipwreck Casserole (7-Layer Dinner)
You may also enjoy PA Dutch chicken and Waffles or these delicious homemade chicken and noodles.
Old-Fashioned Amish Chicken Casseroles Your Family Will Love
The next time you're looking for a quick dinner idea, I hope you'll try one of these tasty Amish chicken casserole recipes. Many of them can be made using leftover or rotisserie chicken, so they're super easy and quick to make.
These Amish chicken casserole recipes are perfect for busy weeknights, Sunday dinners, church potlucks, and cozy family meals. From cheesy noodle casseroles to hearty chicken and rice bakes, these easy, homemade, comfort food dinners are practical, filling, and full of old-fashioned flavor.
Chicken with pasta seems to be a hit in Amish country, and you'll find that most of these chicken casserole recipes feature some kind of pasta.
If you try any of these recipes, I'd love it if you left a comment and star rating below. Thank you and Happy Cooking!
Check out my roundup with 23 Amish-Inspired Dirt Cheap Meals to Feed a Family
Leave a Reply